If you're craving spine-chilling tales to share in the dark, Reddit is a treasure trove of eerie stories that will send shivers down your spine. Here's a curated selection of some of the most unsettling narratives from Reddit's vast horror community:

🔪 Creepy Reddit Tales to Tell in the Dark
1. "Butcherface" by dash32
A renovation project takes a horrifying turn when a hidden box is discovered beneath the floorboards, containing something far more sinister than expected.
Massoud Shaari

2. "The Smiling Man"
A late-night walk turns into a nightmare as the narrator encounters a man with an unsettling smile, leading to a terrifying chase through the city streets.
Teen Vogue

3. "Look at Me"
A teenager, home alone, hears strange noises and discovers disturbing messages written on their door, leading to a chilling realization.
Teen Vogue

4. "My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook"
After his girlfriend's tragic death, Nathan receives messages from her Facebook account, blurring the lines between grief and the supernatural.
Teen Vogue

5. "Dr. Ramsey"
A real-life encounter with a stalker known only as Dr. Ramsey, who terrorizes the narrator with unsettling behavior and threats.
Teen Vogue

📚 Reddit's Take on Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
Reddit users have shared their thoughts on the classic horror anthology Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark. Many recall the unsettling illustrations and tales that left a lasting impression. One user noted, "The books were ok, but didn't capture my imagination. The audiobooks scared the crap out of me and my cousin."
Reddit
+5
Reddit Favorites
+5
Reddit
+5
Reddit Favorites

📖 Bonus: The Tome of Terrifying Tales Vol 1
For those seeking more horror content, Reddit user u/SpookyAuthor compiled a collection of original horror stories from Reddit authors. This non-monetized project offers a variety of tales to keep you up at night. You can access it here:
Reddit
Reddit
+2
Reddit
+2
Reddit
+2